Return to Niles Historical Society Home Page

Back to Photographs

Mayors of Niles Ohio.
By Gene Antonio, Niles Daily Times News Staff, August 7, 1984
(Service dates and images of the mayors have been added).

Since a man named H.H.Mason was elected the first mayor of Niles in 1866, 30 men have served in the city’s highest office. When Niles was no more than a small village, mayors were elected to one-year terms. Later, terms were increased to two years and not long ago they were increased to the present four years.

Each of these mayors made contributions of one type or another to the city and aided in its growth. Some are better known than others, but each has earned a place in the history of the city.

Others serving in the office were W.F. Thomas from 1904 to 1908; Edwin Hall from 1902 to 1904; E. Boynton, from 1900 to 1902; Leonard Holloway from 1896 to 1900. Holloway’s terms were characterized as “strict, precise and conscientious.”

Other early mayors were D.J. Woodford, and William Davis. Davis was mayor when Niles was incorporated as a city in 1884. He served for 18 years, longer than any other mayor.

The earliest mayors were J.B. Noble(1867), John Ohl(1868), F. Casper(1869),
J.H. Fluhart(1870), M.D. Sanderson(1872), Ephriam Thomas(1874),
William Davis(1876-1894), D.J. Woodford(1894), Leonard Holloway(1896-1900),
E. Boynton(1900), Edward Hall(1902), W.F. Thomas(1904-1908).

1914 Niles officials.

On the front of the picture they are identified from left to right:

1. Police Chief L. Round,
2. O. R. Farror
3. Bert Holloway, Supt. of Water & Light Dept. 4. Mayor Frank Bryan. PO1.1085

Charles Crow served as mayor from 1916 to 1924, the second longest amount of service. Crow was a minor league baseball player and arrived in Niles on a freight train. He owned the Niles Shoe Store for many years and during his years in office saw the dedication of the McKinley Memorial and Library.

His service was characterized as being “like a breath of fresh air” and he was re-elected with the largest majority ever received as a candidate up to that time. Characterized as “genial, impulsive, and big-hearted,” Crow fought a war against organized crime which he said produced “a new type of criminal.”

Although he himself fought corruption, Crow was called before the state to answer corruption charges. He was vindicated but the publicity cost him the election in 1924. He lost by 450 votes to Harvey Kistler, who had the political support of the KKK.

Kistler fought against vice* in the city and was instrumental in obtaining the land where Meander Reservoir is now located.

He also did work leading to Niles’ being part of the Mahoning Valley Sanitary District.

Kistler also laid the groundwork for construction of the viaduct. The Viaduct was dedicated in 1933.

*Vice refers to bootleggers, numbers rackets, and gambling. Prohibition was in effect during Kistler's tenure as Mayor.

In 1924 there were confrontations between the Italian/Irish community and the KKK.

Harvey Kistler believed that the KKK had the legal right to receive a permit to march in a Niles' parade. The Irish-Italian community attacked the parade in May and June. A truce was brokered with concessions from both sides, however this truce was short-lived.

The 1924 Riot refers to the November 1, 1924 melee that took place throughout several key areas in Niles that day.

The largest confrontation occurred at the intersection of North Main Street and West Federal Avenue when the Italian-Irish group prevented the KKK from crossing the Erie Railroad tracks and marching into downtown Niles.

A limited Civil Martial Law was put in place when the Ohio National Guard arrived and dispersed both sides.

Dedicated in 1933 during the term of Mayor E.C. Ferguson PO1.70

E.C. Ferguson(1932-1935) served two terms.

During his tenure Niles celebrated its centennial in 1934. Also during this period, the Niles Bank building was constructed on South Main Street and West Park Avenue.

From 1936 to 1938 Fred R. Williams served as mayor.

During the transitional period between the Depression and the war, William P. Kearney(1938-1941) served two terms as mayor. Under Kearney, electrical wires downtown were installed underground. Niles was one of the few cities at that time to make this improvement.

Also under Kearney, working through the WPA, a major resurfacing project was carried out in the city. During the Kearney administration, through Congressman Michael Kirwan, Niles received as much assistance from the WPA per capita as any city in the country.

Waddell Park and specifically the Niles Municipal Pool greatly benefitted from the assistance of the WPA in its construction and the employment of Niles unemployed workers. The new Post Office on Park Avenue also was a construction project funded through the WPA.

Joseph Parise (1988-1991)

Mayor Joseph Cicero(1980-1983), had as the important feature of his tenure a period of fiscal accomplishments in which the city was restored to economic solvency.

Cicero inherited a fiscal emergency when he took office. The city was deeply in debt, with Niles the first city in the state to be declared in fiscal emergency under a new law. As mayor, Cicero put the city back in the black.

John Shaffer (1984-1987)

Mayor, John Shaffer(1984-1987) ran on a platform of seeking industry and commercial businesses for the city, as well as a beautification and litter control program.

Thomas Scarnecchia (2016-2018)

Barry Steffey, Jr (2018, Interim)

Steven Mientkiewicz (2018-Present).

Steve ran on a platform focusing on:
Fiscal Responsibility, removing neighborhood blight, improving the infrastructure of water and sewer lines, and community outreach through social media.

In March 2019, Niles was successfully removed from Fiscal Emergency.